Deer-caused auto deaths are up nationwide, in Utah
This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2008, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

Posted: 4:21 PM- As two-legged population increases in Utah and across the country, people are having more fatal encounters with the four-hoofed population, data show.

A report by the Highway Loss Data Institute showed that 223 people nationwide died in animal-vehicle crashes last year, up from 150 in 2000 and 101 in 1993.

The trend has extended to Utah, which recorded zero fatal crashes with animals in 1993, but had four last year. There were 36 such deaths in Utah from 1993 to 2007.

The Loss Data Institute blames urban sprawl for the problem and said the vast majority of the deaths occurred when a vehicle struck a deer. And the sponsors warned that now is the time for drivers to be on the lookout.

The study found insurance claims for crashes with animals are three times higher in November, when animals are breeding, than it is from January to September.

Terry Messmer, a professor of wildlife conflict management at Utah State University, has been following deer-vehicle collisions since coming to Utah 18 years ago. He says the number of incidents is on the rise, perhaps because more are being reported.

"Highways cross a lot of migration corridors," Messmer said.

Thus far in 2008, the Utah Highway Patrol has logged two fatal animal accidents. In April, a motorist died when a car struck a cow. In June, another one died after a vehicle struck a deer.

Summit County Sheriff Dave Edmunds said his officers respond almost every day to a car striking a deer, elk or moose. Like most people with a firsthand view of the problem, Edmunds blames sprawl. Summit County has seen houses rise on mountain slopes and meadows that are prime habitat for large herbivores.

"If you're driving in rural Utah, it's not a matter of if you're going to hit a deer," Edmunds said. "It's when."

Even Edmunds' office is not immune. In February, a Summit County deputy was driving on Interstate 80 through Parleys Canyon, and his cruiser struck a moose laying in the road. Another car hit the moose moments earlier. Edmunds said the deputy suffered minor leg injuries and has returned to duty.

The Utah Division of Wildlife Resources and Utah Department of Transportation are working on getting better numbers, but say their best estimate for Utah deer killed in collisions is about 10,000 each year.

That is about one-third the number of deer killed by hunters in an average year, according to DWR big game coordinator Anise Aoude. But whereas hunters target bucks, about 7,000 female deer die in collisions.

The loss of deer to collisions "is very significant, not because of the number but because of the makeup," Aoude said. "When we hunt, the harvest is only males that do not bear young so it is not as detrimental to the population."

Highway planners and wildlife officials have tried different methods to prevent auto-deer collisions, often with little success. They include trying to use crosswalks to lure deer across highways in critical spots, ultrasound devices placed on cars and a new study using infrared sensors being conducted in Yellowstone National Park.

Messmer said two methods seem to work best.

One of the most common is warning signs in areas where deer migrate across highways. The agencies also have used temporary warning signs that are even more obvious to drivers.

But the most efficient method, Messner said, is building a transportation system that separates animals from traffic, using underpasses and overpasses combined with fencing. "We try to funnel them into corridors and encourage rather than restrict animal movement."

ncarlisle@sltrib.com

wharton@sltrib.com

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS contributed to this report.

Article Tools

Enter a search phrase.

Specify a Range

From  to

 

 
Missing your paper? Need to place your paper on vacation hold? For this and any other subscription related needs, click here or call 801.204.6100.